• Home
  • About Us
  • Meet The Team
  • Practice Areas
    • Defamation Law
    • Internet Law
    • Corporate Law
    • Ecommerce Law
    • Advertising Law
    • Social Media Law
  • Internet Law Blog
  • Contact Us

Call Toll Free 1-866-570-8585

Find An Office Near You
Speak With an Internet Lawyer Now
RM Warner Law | Online, Marketing, Internet Business Law FirmRM Warner Law | Online, Marketing, Internet Business Law Firm
RM Warner Law | Online, Marketing, Internet Business Law FirmRM Warner Law | Online, Marketing, Internet Business Law Firm
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Meet The Team
  • Practice Areas
    • Defamation Law
    • Internet Law
    • Corporate Law
    • Ecommerce Law
    • Advertising Law
    • Social Media Law
  • Internet Law Blog
  • Contact Us
man typing on computer | RM Warner Inernet Law Firm

Customer Review Defamation Lawsuit: Ripoff Report Case Study

October 3, 2019 Posted by Daniel Warner Advertising Law, Business Law, Defamation, Internet Law No Comments

Have you ever used the website Ripoff Report to write a negative customer review about a company who you felt “ripped you off”? Have you ever been threatened with a lawsuit because of your comments? Let’s look into a real-life Ripoff Report case and review the basic requirements for winning an online trade libel case.

Numerous defamation lawsuits stem from disgruntled customers posting online reviews of products or businesses that they feel they’ve had a negative experience with. Many cases that we’ve worked on with clients have come from the popular consumer review website, Ripoff Report.

Below, we will review a defamation case between a Florida woman and a hot tub company and discuss the differences between negative online reviews and defamatory ones.

RIPOFF REPORT CASE STUDY:

A woman (we’ll call her “Jenny”) bought a hot tub that she claimed to have a problem.

“The spa leaked the first time I used it,” she explained, “so [the hot tub company] had it repaired. But then it leaked again. My carpet stank from the water and I wanted a refund.”

When Jenny brought this issue up to the company she had purchased the spa from, they reminded her of the “no return policy”. This limited her options to paying a 10% restocking fee or $800 for a new tub, which escalated the situation even more.

In the end, Jenny’s credit card company reversed the charges, but she posted her version of the experience with the company on Ripoff Report, causing the spa’s reputation to take a hit.

In pursuit of restoring their reputation, the hot tub company decided to sue Jenny for defamation.

Can they win?

WINNING A CUSTOMER REVIEW DEFAMATION LAWSUIT: REQUIRED PROOF

Generally, it’s not easy to win a customer review defamation lawsuit. This is because free speech is a national right according to the First Amendment. Therefore, at a minimum, in the majority of states, plaintiffs must be able to establish the following by a “preponderance of the evidence” (i.e., more likely than not):

  1. Falsity: Small mistakes or exaggerations are not enough. To win a defamation lawsuit, the problematic statement must be a false statement of fact — and the plaintiff must prove that it is.
  2. Harm: In most cases, businesses that file defamation lawsuits must provide evidence that the false statement of fact had a direct, financial impact on their business.
  3. Negligence: Proving harm and falsity still won’t cut it. Plaintiffs also need to convince a judge or jury that the defendant either didn’t engage in enough fact checking before publishing or knew the statement was false but posted it anyway.

It’s important to consider all the facts and circumstances before filing a lawsuit as a result of an online review. And more times than not, these facts and circumstances include a lot more than the basic requirements discussed above. For example, does labeling something an opinion make it so? Can you still win a defamation lawsuit? Contact the experienced defamation lawyers at RM Warner Law to get all of the answers and insight you need.

To learn more about removing defamatory content from RipOff Report, Click Here.

Tags: defamationdefamation lawsuitfake reviewreview removalripoff report
No Comments
Share
0

About Daniel Warner

As a partner at RM Warner, Daniel focuses the majority of his practice on litigating cases involving Internet defamation, false and misleading advertising/marketing, unfair competition and cyber harassment. Although based in Arizona, Dan Warner has litigated Internet defamation cases in California, Texas, Nevada, Pennsylvania, New York, Georgia, North Carolina and Florida, as well as numerous cases in Arizona. Mr. Warner also works on various contractual, commercial, business, real estate, Internet and Internet marketing matters.

You also might be interested in

judge hitting wooden gavel | RM Warner Inernet Law Firm

Can Jussie Smollett be Sued for Defamation?

May 4, 2019

If you’ve been paying attention to the news recently, you’ve[...]

girl crying next to computer | RM Warner Inernet Law Firm

Sextortion Targets College Students in Idaho

May 8, 2019

Have you ever received a friend request or direct message[...]

michael jackson getting out of car | RM Warner Inernet Law Firm

Michael Jackson Estate Sues HBO for $100 Million Over “Leaving Neverland”

May 10, 2019

The life, career, and death of Michael Jackson has had[...]

Leave a Reply

Your email is safe with us.
Cancel Reply

Recent Posts

  • When Should You Hire a YouTube Lawyer to Help With Your Channel?
  • Removing Content About Yourself From the Internet
  • What Can Lawyers Do About Negative Online Reviews?
  • Why Hire a Lawyer for Your Online Small Business
  • Advertising Law: Everything You Need to Know

Recent Comments

  • Raees Mohamed on Cyberbullying Lawyer: How to Sue for Cyberbullying with Defamation Laws
  • Sylvia Richards on Cyberbullying Lawyer: How to Sue for Cyberbullying with Defamation Laws
  • WebDirectory on Can I Sue Someone For Leaking My ‘OnlyFans’ Content?
  • Links.M106.COM on Dr. Dre’s Divorce Battle Is Nothing But a “G” Thang: Soon-To-Be Ex-Wife Fights For the Intellectual Property Rights to His Name
  • Website directory on Can Jussie Smollett be Sued for Defamation?

Contact Us

Send us a message and we'll get back to you, asap.

Send Message
Speak With An Internet Lawyer Today Call Now

© 2020 — RM Warner Law

  • RM Warner Instagram
  • Blog
  • Terms of Service
Prev Next